From a hyper-local artisan roast served at an unexpected backyard BBQ spot to a hidden gem just over the bridge in Cortez, here are the top five places to get your caffeine fix on and around Anna Maria Island.
Whether you are waking up early to catch a sunrise at Bean Point or cooling off after a long afternoon in the Gulf, finding a stellar cup of coffee is an essential part of the Anna Maria Island (AMI) experience. While this beautiful Florida barrier island is famous for its sugary sand beaches and laid-back retro charm, its coffee scene is equally impressive.
From a hyper-local artisan roast served at an unexpected backyard BBQ spot to a hidden gem just over the bridge in Cortez, here are the top five places to get your caffeine fix on and around Anna Maria Island.
1. gRub Tropical BBQ
You might not expect a premier coffee experience at a barbecue joint, but gRub Tropical BBQ on Pine Avenue completely shatters that expectation. Aside from serving up phenomenal island-style smoked meats, they serve outstanding Brewed Monday coffee.
The team at Brewed Monday takes immense pride in sourcing single-origin, 100% traceable, high-quality beans, and it truly shows in the final cup. If you get a chance to chat with Nick, one of the founders of Brewed Monday, you will quickly appreciate the passion they have for sourcing great beans.
Must-Try Drink: The Dark Roast. It's rich, incredibly smooth, and expertly brewed.
The Vibe: Casual, welcoming, and an absolute local favorite.
2. North End Coffee Boutique
Tucked away on the northern side of the island, North End Coffee Boutique is a dream for aesthetic lovers and serious coffee drinkers alike. The presentation here is unmatched, adding a wonderfully unique touch to your morning ritual.
Must-Try Drink: Their Iced Latte. It is perfectly balanced, but the real highlight is that it's served in an ultra-sleek glass can. Very Instagrammable.
The Vibe: Modern, upscale, yet totally relaxed. It is the perfect place to grab a refreshing drink to-go before walking down to the beach.
3. The Donut Experiment
If your ideal morning includes pairing a fresh, custom-glazed pastry with a high-quality brew, The Donut Experiment is a mandatory stop. While they are famous for their warm, made-to-order donuts, their coffee is no afterthought.
Must-Try Drink: A simple, classic Filter Coffee. While people flock here for the sugar rush, coffee purists will appreciate how clean and robust their standard drip is.
The Vibe: Bustling, family-friendly, and interactive.
4. North Shore Cafe
Located right on Pine Avenue, North Shore Cafe features a gorgeous, breezy backyard seating area right on the waterfront. While their standard espresso drinks skew a bit milder and less intense than a heavy dark roast, they make up for it with some of the most creative concoctions on the island.
Must-Try Drink: The Matcha Latte for tea lovers, or the Off Shore Smoothie—a blend of cold brew coffee, acai, blueberry, almond butter, and almond milk (definitely more of a smoothie than a typical coffee).
The Vibe: Ultimate Florida tropical chill. It is an amazing spot to sit outside, relax under the palms, and sip a specialty drink.
5. The Fox Mercantile (Cortez)
While technically located just seconds off the island over the Cortez Bridge, The Fox Mercantile easily earns its spot on this list. Frankly, it serves some of the absolute best coffee you will find anywhere on or off the island.
Must-Try Drink: The flat white. If you enjoy strong coffee, this will not disappoint.
The Vibe: A stunning, curated retail and café space with a lovely shaded outdoor seating area. Warning: it's almost a given that you'll see something to buy in the boutique.
Tips for the Ultimate AMI Coffee Crawl
Parking Tip: Before driving to Pine Avenue, check current parking options and obey the posted signs and markings at your chosen space. Rules vary by location.
Beat the Crowds: Spots like The Donut Experiment get incredibly busy by mid-morning. Head out early to secure your brew without the lines.
If you have a favorite cup of joe that's not on the list, let us know in the comments and we'll check it out.
